Independent restaurant-inspired recipes • Shop ingredients at Walmart • Affiliate disclosure applies
Illustrative finished homemade recreation of Beef 'n Cheddar-style Sandwich
Illustrative image of an independent homemade recreation. Not official restaurant photography.
Arby's inspired

Beef 'n Cheddar-style Sandwich

Homemade recreation25–35 minEasyServes 4

See the recognizable build, then make a similar version using easy-to-find grocery ingredients.

What’s on the restaurant item?
roast beefonion rollcheddar saucetangy red sauce

Component descriptions are informational summaries. Restaurant recipes and availability can change by market.

How to make a similar version

1
Warm the roast beef gently in a covered skillet with a splash of broth; do not boil.
2
Toast the roll lightly.
3
Prepare cheese sauce, tangy sauce or au jus as listed.
4
Pile the warm beef high on the roll and add sauce.
5
Serve immediately.
Closer-match tip
Warm deli roast beef gently; high heat makes it tough and dry.

Build the ingredient list

· estimated remaining basket $14.92*
4
Roast Beef1 package · Search: deli roast beef
~$5.98
Onion Roll1 package · Search: onion rolls
~$3.48
Cheddar Sauce1 package · Search: cheddar cheese sauce
~$2.48
Tangy Red Sauce1 package · Search: tangy sandwich sauce
~$2.98
Search Walmart
*Package-price estimates are illustrative and vary by location, brand, size and availability. CraveCart may earn a commission from qualifying purchases made through retailer links, at no additional cost to you.
More from Arby's

Keep recreating.